The Price of Pleasure · Part 2 of 4

The Bill

Five men before the first euro stays with her. And a state that raises the rent out of decency.

A series by Mistress Alexa, Munich · 7 min read

Part 1 was about the man who thinks 50 euros is reasonable. Today is about the woman who receives it. More precisely: about how much of it she gets to keep.

The answer is sobering. And it only partly has to do with men.

I.The arithmetic of a working day

A room in a Munich establishment costs, according to what colleagues consistently tell me, around 200 euros on average. Per day. Whether clients come or not. Whether she is ill or not. Whether she feels like it or not.

Let us calculate with the price the man from Part 1 considers fair: 50 euros.

  • The first man pays a quarter of the rent.
  • The second, half.
  • The third, three quarters.
  • The fourth, the rest.
  • Advertising, taxes, condoms, lubricant, laundry, disinfectant, travel costs, mandatory counselling sessions: nobody has paid for any of that yet.

The fifth man is, depending on the day, the first one from whom she earns anything.

Let that sentence sink in for a moment. A woman has to have been intimate with four or five strange men before her day even begins to pay. Every man after that is her wage. Every cancellation, every quiet Tuesday, every bout of flu is a loss she carries alone.

In any other industry, nobody would call that "self-employed". They would call it debt bondage at a daily rate.

II.What does it say about us?

We live in a society that debates delivery riders, parcel couriers, seasonal farm workers, fair wages for coffee growers on other continents. And rightly so.

We do not talk to the woman in the flat three streets away, the one who needs the fourth man to pay her rent. At most we talk about her, in a lowered voice, with a joke, with a shrug. Well, she chose it.

Did she? And if so: under what conditions?

III.The state as reluctant landlord

Now it gets uncomfortable, because the punter is not the only one with a hand in this bill. The state has a seat at the table too.

In Germany, prostitution has been legal since 2002 and is no longer considered a business contrary to public morals. The Prostitution Act (Prostitutionsgesetz, ProstG) made that clear. At the same time, the federal states may decide by ordinance where it may be practised. The legal basis is Article 297 of the Introductory Act to the Criminal Code (EGStGB). It permits a ban "for the protection of young people or of public decency" (my translation).

Of public decency. You have to read that phrase twice.

Munich has made generous use of it. A Sperrbezirk — a restricted zone where sex work is banned — covers by far the greater part of the city. Sex work is essentially permitted on the outskirts and in industrial estates, in a few houses that are allowed to stand exactly there. Anyone who breaches the restricted zone commits an administrative offence (§ 120 OWiG, the German Administrative Offences Act); anyone who does so persistently commits a criminal offence (§ 184f StGB, the German Criminal Code).

What happens when you concentrate a legal trade on a handful of addresses? Any first-year economics student can explain it: the supply of rooms becomes artificially scarce, demand stays the same. Rents rise. And whoever owns the rooms holds a market power no free market would ever have given them.

The woman who could work independently in her own flat, safely, quietly, on her own terms, is not allowed to in large parts of the city. She has to go where it is permitted. And there she pays the price the landlord sets.

Public decency thus becomes a source of income for a few landlords. And a fixed-cost trap for the women.

IV.Is this human trafficking?

Legally: no. Human trafficking under § 232 StGB requires that someone recruits, transports or harbours a person by exploiting a predicament or helplessness, in order to exploit them. A state that sets restricted zones does not do that. I am not making that accusation.

But one may ask a different question: who profits when women with high daily rents slide into dependency? Who finds their victims more easily among women who are 200 euros in debt before the first client, day after day? The business model of exploitation lives on exactly this predicament. And the state did not invent the predicament, but it has cast it in concrete.

A regulation that wants to protect women and in doing so pushes them into dependency is no longer protection. It is well-meant complicity.

V.The legal view: what the Basic Law says

I am not a lawyer, and this is not legal advice. But the German Basic Law (Grundgesetz, GG), the country's constitution, was not written for lawyers, it was written for everyone. So let us read it.

Article 12(1) GG: "All Germans shall have the right freely to choose their occupation or profession, their place of work and their place of training. The practice of an occupation or profession may be regulated by or pursuant to a law." (English translation)

That sex work is an occupation within the meaning of this article is broadly recognised today. As early as 2000, the Administrative Court of Berlin (VG Berlin) found that prostitution, practised voluntarily and without coercion, is no longer contrary to public morals by today's values. The Prostitution Act of 2002 and the Prostitute Protection Act (Prostituiertenschutzgesetz, ProstSchG) of 2017, which requires registration, health counselling and a licence for establishments, presuppose exactly that: you only regulate what you recognise as an occupation.

How far the state may interfere with an occupation has been governed since 1958 by the so-called three-stage theory of the Federal Constitutional Court (BVerfG) (the Pharmacy judgment, 1 BvR 596/56):

  1. Rules on how an occupation is practised (regulation of practice) are permissible as long as they are supported by reasonable considerations of the common good.
  2. Subjective conditions of entry, i.e. requirements a person can meet themselves (examinations, qualifications), require the protection of an important community interest.
  3. Objective conditions of entry, i.e. hurdles over which the person has no influence, are only permitted to avert demonstrable or highly probable serious dangers to an overridingly important community interest.

A restricted zone is classically regarded as a rule of the first stage: it does not ban the occupation, it only says where. That is why courts have so far regularly upheld restricted zones.

My reading: this classification only holds as long as the permitted locations genuinely allow the occupation to be practised freely. When it comes to fundamental rights, the Federal Constitutional Court looks not only at the form of an interference but at its effect. If a rule about location means that a woman in a city of a million people can in practice only pursue her occupation on terms that leave her no economic room of her own, then the rule acts like an objective condition of entry. And then "public decency" no longer suffices as a justification. Decency is an honourable sentiment. An overridingly important community interest that averts serious dangers, it is not.

Then there is Article 1 GG, human dignity. The state likes to invoke it when it restricts sex work. In 1981 the Federal Administrative Court (BVerwG) even banned peep shows because they violated the dignity of the women, even though they performed voluntarily. One can argue about that. But if dignity is the measure, then it must also apply to the woman who is working today: her dignity is not violated by the occupation she chose. Her dignity is violated by an order in which she has to serve four men before her day belongs to her.

A state that wants to protect dignity should enable women to work on their own terms: in their own rooms, at their own prices, with their own limits. Not push them to the edge of town and then be surprised at who is waiting for them there.

VI.And me?

All of this affects me less, and I say so openly. I do not offer sex. No intercourse, no oral sex. I work in a studio whose room I reserve for a session, and I set my own fee. I can afford to say no.

That is exactly why I am writing this. Because self-determination should not be the privilege of a dominatrix, but the very least a society owes every woman who works with her body.

In the next part I explain why a man who goes to a dominatrix has learned something that many a punter lacks. It has to do with respect. And surprisingly little with pain.


Legal notes: This text reflects a personal opinion and a general constitutional assessment, not legal advice. Sources: Art. 1, Art. 12 GG; Art. 297 EGStGB; § 120 OWiG; § 184f, § 232 StGB; Prostitution Act (ProstG) 2002; Prostitute Protection Act (ProstSchG) 2017, §§ 3, 10, 12; BVerfG, judgment of 11.06.1958, 1 BvR 596/56 (Pharmacy judgment); VG Berlin, judgment of 01.12.2000, 35 A 570.99; BVerwG, judgment of 15.12.1981, 1 C 232.79 (peep show). The daily rent of around €200 is based on information from colleagues, not on an official survey.

All thoughts

When you are ready

Arrange a session

Sessions in German or English, in Munich or by video. Discretion goes without saying.

Choose a time

No intercourse, no oral sex.